Retail media ROI still doesn’t add up for most brands, even as spending on retail media hits record highs. US retail media ad spend is set to reach roughly $71 billion in 2026, up about 18 percent from 2025, according to eMarketer. That’s faster growth than social or search advertising. Here’s the part that should worry you: most of the brands paying into that $71 billion still can’t prove it’s working.
Key Takeaways
- US retail media ad spend is projected to reach about $71 billion in 2026, roughly 18 percent above 2025, per eMarketer.
- Amazon Ads and Walmart Connect are set to capture about 89 percent of that incremental growth, per eMarketer, cited by Global Brands Magazine.
- More than 200 retail media networks exist and are splitting what’s left, per Digiday.
- Only 15 percent of marketers say they can measure retail media incrementality effectively, and the IAB’s own trade body says the market “cannot sustain hundreds of undifferentiated commerce media networks.”
Why Is Retail Media Spending Growing So Fast?
Retailers built these networks on money that was already budgeted. Brands had trade and shopper marketing contracts with Walmart, Target, and Kroger long before “retail media network” was a line item, so retailers simply relabeled existing spend as media revenue. That’s an easy way to post growth. Layer on real demand too: Walmart Connect’s revenue grew 31 percent in its fiscal 2026 first quarter, and its US retail media business excluding Vizio grew 44 percent, per Walmart’s results, cited by Global Brands Magazine. It’s the same consolidation logic we flagged in Fox’s $22 billion Roku deal reshaping connected TV advertising: when a few platforms already hold the budget and the data, growth flows to them first.
But growth built on reallocated trade budgets has a ceiling. The IAB Tech Lab’s Connected Commerce Summit heard exactly that this fall. Collin Colburn, the IAB’s VP of commerce and retail media, put it bluntly: “Growth in the future hinges on access to national and brand media budgets, not by trade or shopper reallocation alone,” per AdExchanger’s reporting on the summit. The easy money is already spent. What comes next has to be earned.
Why Doesn’t Retail Media ROI Add Up Yet?
Here’s the uncomfortable number. Only 15 percent of marketers say they can effectively measure retail media incrementality, meaning whether an ad actually caused a sale rather than just appearing near one that would’ve happened anyway, per eMarketer’s research. Most teams default to ROAS, return on ad spend, as a stand-in. ROAS counts any sale near an impression. Incrementality asks whether that sale would’ve happened without the ad. Those aren’t the same question, and mixing them up is how a retailer can hand you a glowing dashboard while your real lift sits near zero.
An earlier survey from Skai and the Path to Purchase Institute found 62 percent of retail media buyers cite a lack of measurement standards as a key barrier, even though confidence in incrementality measurement had climbed to 56 percent from 30 percent the year before. That data is from February 2025, so treat it as a snapshot of a fast-moving problem, not today’s number. But the direction matters: measurement is improving off a low base, not solved.
I wouldn’t take a retailer’s incrementality claim at face value. Ask what methodology produced it and whether it holds up under outside scrutiny. We ran into a version of this same trust gap covering how AI Mode is growing while the attribution data around it shrinks: platforms grow fastest exactly when it gets hardest to check their numbers independently.
What Happens to the 200-Plus Networks That Aren’t Amazon or Walmart?
Digiday’s reporting on agency sentiment this fall found executives openly describing a “point of diminishing returns” in retail media, the same phrase you’d apply to any media type once you’ve bought up all the good inventory. Rob Douglas, CEO of the agency Left Off Madison, told Digiday he discourages clients from “blind faith” investment in networks that haven’t proven their efficacy. Wpromote VP Sammy Rubin advises sorting networks into core, secondary, and longer-tail tiers instead of funding them all equally.
Pricing spread tells the same story. It’s uneven across formats, and that gap is a decent proxy for how uneven real demand is too.
| Format | Typical CPM |
|---|---|
| On-site display | About $15 |
| Off-site display | $8 to $9 |
| Social placements | About $12 |
| Connected TV | About $33 |
CPM figures per Digiday’s reporting on agency estimates. Retailers are also pushing 10 to 20 percent annual increases in spend commitments, per the same reporting, which squeezes brands that can’t yet prove the current spend is working.
What Should Marketers Do About the Retail Media ROI Gap?
- Demand incrementality testing, not just ROAS, before renewing any network contract.
- Ask whether an outside party, not the retailer selling the inventory, validated the lift number you were shown.
- Sort retail media partners into core, secondary, and longer-tail tiers, and fund them unevenly on purpose.
- Push back on automatic spend increases until measurement improves, not after.
- Watch national and brand budget allocation, not trade dollars, as the real signal of whether a network earns new money or just relabels old money.
FAQ
Is retail media advertising still worth it in 2026? For networks with real scale and believable measurement, yes, growth is real and Walmart Connect’s 31 percent revenue jump shows genuine demand. For the long tail of 200-plus smaller networks, the case is weaker until they show independently validated incrementality.
What’s the difference between ROAS and incrementality in retail media? ROAS counts sales near an ad exposure, including ones that would’ve happened anyway. Incrementality isolates sales the ad actually caused, usually through holdout tests, and it’s the harder, more honest number.
Will Amazon and Walmart end up controlling most retail media spend? They already capture roughly 89 percent of the category’s incremental growth in 2026, per eMarketer, so that’s a current fact for anyone planning a 2027 budget, not a future risk.
How many retail media networks does a typical brand use? Survey data from Skai and the Path to Purchase Institute put the average around six networks in 2025, with brands expecting that number to keep climbing.
Sources: Global Brands Magazine, citing eMarketer and Walmart’s fiscal 2026 Q1 results; AdExchanger’s report on the IAB Tech Lab Connected Commerce Summit; Digiday’s reporting on agency sentiment toward retail media returns; Marketing Dive on questions agencies should ask before investing in commerce media networks; Chain Drug Review’s coverage of the Skai and Path to Purchase Institute State of Retail Media survey.